Do Children Make Parents Miserable or Happy? Yes.
In 2010 journalist Jennifer Senior wrote an article in New York Magazine that explored research suggesting, “parents are not happier than their childless peers, and in many cases are less so.” The article was backed by creditable statistics and research. Obviously, it was controversial and hotly contested.
Yesterday the New York Times ran a story about two college professors, Chris M. Herbst and John Ifcher, who are challenging that earlier assumption, reporting, “Being a parent . . . really does make people happier than the alternative.”
And Global News reported on three additional studies from Stanford, the University of California, Riverside, and the University of British Columbia who have collaborated on a paper titled, ‘In Defense of Parenthood: Children Are Associated With More Joy Than Misery.’
What’s the real story? I can only speak for myself, having had no children at one point and then having in subsequent order one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, and then nine (we skipped eight except for the four minutes between the two twins).
I agree with Jennifer Senior that children can truly make one’s day, week, month, year and even decade miserable. My wife and I certainly weren’t happy to clean up projectile vomit over twenty years or change approximately 36,000 diapers (Cost? $20,000 give or take a couple of grand). We were also not happy when our children lied to us about critical events in their lives. We weren’t happy when we had to increase car insurance costs for collisions. We were actually quite miserable when we had to hold children down in hospital chairs to have their bones reset or have gashes stitched shut.
No, we weren’t thrilled when our friends were vacationing in Hawaii or rafting down the Grand Canyon and we were rocking twins all night long because they had ear infections, and those nights went on for days, weeks and months until we literally collapsed from exhaustion and a neighbor came in and did our laundry.
Also, nothing is quite as painful as when a child, during a ridiculous argument says, “I hate you!”And, for those of you who say, “Don’t take it personally,” believe me, they mean it when they say it.
And, if a child dies . . . no words can convey the sadness, grief and pain you experience. And you always wonder, what might have been.
However, children have also given us tremendous joy. That first breath is a miracle. That first smile, their first steps, their first words, their first drawing, their first bike, their first day of school, their first discovery of butterflies are all magical moments. When they learn to write and read and discover books it is simply amazing. When children hug you and say they love you, it softens your heart. Their unbridled joy at jumping through sprinklers or running through fields of tall grass with their arms outstretched like wings is a joy to behold.
And when they grow up and discover for themselves that they can think, and act, and work, and live, and decide, and change the world, it is wonderful.
Yes, having children is painful and we agree that you can, at times, be less than happy compared to your friends who are childless. But for me, having children has been the most important educational experience I could ever have hoped for. I’ve learned to love and give and share and teach and listen and play and sing and rejoice in what they bring. Children reopen a world we once had and somewhere lost along the way during our transition to adulthood.
So, I think both studies are correct. Each couple who has the ability to have children has their own agency to choose what life they want—one with children or one without. My wife and I chose to have children and it’s been an infinitely blessed experience, misery and joy, grief and laughter. All the above.
“One of the great discoveries of parenthood is that we learn far more about what really matters from our children than we ever did from our parents.” —Boyd Packer